When it comes to remodeling your bathroom, one of the biggest decisions you'll face is choosing between a bathtub and a shower. Each option comes with its own set of benefits and considerations. Depending on your lifestyle, budget, and aesthetic preferences, either a bathtub or a shower could be the perfect addition to your home. Here, we weigh the pros and cons of each to help guide your decision-making process for the ideal bathroom remodel. Working with an experienced bathroom remodeler can also help clarify which option best fits your space and style.

Consider Room Size

First, consider the space available in your bathroom. Showers generally require less space than bathtubs, making them a better choice for smaller bathrooms. If your bathroom is limited in square footage, a sleek, modern shower can create the illusion of more space and offer a cleaner aesthetic. On the other hand, if you have ample space, a luxurious bathtub can become a focal point and a statement piece in your bathroom design. A bathroom remodeler can help you assess your layout to determine which option maximizes your available space.

Reflect on Specific Lifestyle

Next, reflect on your lifestyle and personal needs. If you have a fast-paced lifestyle and prefer efficiency, a shower might be ideal, allowing for quick refreshing moments. Conversely, if you cherish long, relaxing soaks after a hectic day, a bathtub can offer the tranquil, spa-like experience you crave. For families with young children, a bathtub can be more practical for bath time, providing more flexibility and fun for the little ones.

Review Project Budget

Budget is another crucial consideration during any bathroom remodel. According to The Spruce, the average cost for a bathroom remodel is $12,000, with the range spanning from $6,700 to $17,600. Typically, installing a shower is more cost-effective compared to installing a bathtub, especially when considering labor and materials. If finances are a key factor in your decision-making, it's important to consider how either option fits into your overall budget.

Evaluate Maintenance Needs

Maintenance and cleaning might sway your choice between a bathtub and a shower. Showers with fewer nooks and crannies are generally easier to clean and maintain, reducing the time spent on chores. Bathtubs, particularly those with jets or intricate designs, can be more labor-intensive to keep clean and free from mold or mildew. Therefore, consider how much time and effort you're willing to invest in maintaining your bathroom's cleanliness when making your decision. A knowledgeable bathroom remodeler can recommend materials and designs that simplify long-term upkeep.

Think About Resale Value

Finally, think about the future resale value of your home. Depending on the market and buyers' preferences, having both a bathtub and a shower in your home could appeal to a broader audience. In master bathrooms, a combination of both often adds value and luxury appeal. However, in smaller, secondary bathrooms, opting for a well-designed shower might suffice and maintain appeal for future buyers. Ensuring your choice aligns with what prospective buyers may look for could make a difference when it's time to sell your home.

Prioritize Aesthetic Preferences

Your overall design vision plays a major role when deciding between a bathtub and a shower. Bathtubs often create a timeless, luxurious atmosphere that complements traditional or spa-inspired interiors. From freestanding soaking tubs to elegant clawfoot styles, they can serve as a bold visual centerpiece. Showers, on the other hand, lend themselves to sleek, modern aesthetics. Frameless glass enclosures, tile accents, and built-in niches can give your bathroom a streamlined, contemporary feel. Considering how each option aligns with your desired look ensures your remodel feels cohesive and visually appealing.

Address Accessibility Needs

Another key factor to weigh is accessibility, especially if you or a family member has mobility challenges. Walk-in showers provide easier entry and exit, and they can be customized with grab bars, bench seating, and low or zero-threshold designs for added safety. Bathtubs, while inviting, require stepping over a higher edge, which may not be ideal for those with limited mobility. Planning for long-term accessibility can help ensure your bathroom remains comfortable, functional, and safe for years to come.



Choosing between a bathtub and a shower for your bathroom remodel requires careful consideration of several factors: space, lifestyle, budget, maintenance, and resale value. Each option has its distinct advantages and can dramatically change the ambiance and functionality of your bathroom. By evaluating what's most important for your personal needs and your home's specific situation, you can ensure that your bathroom remodel adds both enjoyment and value to your property. If you're looking for a professional bathroom remodeler, make sure to get in touch with Klotzbach Custom Builders & Remodelers today!